Forumite Members › General Topics › Tech › Windows Talk › Nokia & windows phone.
- This topic has 24 replies, 9 voices, and was last updated 7 years, 8 months ago by
The Duke.
-
AuthorPosts
-
June 30, 2018 at 9:30 am #22451
So, tech wise phones R of no interest to me.
So What happend to windows phones and the app store??
I see Nokia release new phones but I thought M$ owned them?
June 30, 2018 at 9:56 am #22452The following is a very abbreviated version of the full Nokia story here.
Microsoft bought (and accidentally killed) the Nokia manufacturing setup as a factory to make the ill-fated (no app developer support) Windows phone. Most reviewers liked the phone’s build quality but said the Windows Store products were sparse and not very good and as a result panned the phone.
Nokia retained the brand-name and a large number of their key development engineers.
All told a big M$ fail, and a long-term monetary win for Nokia.
June 30, 2018 at 12:22 pm #22453Another instance of M$ attempting catch up by buying companies and milking the best from them. This one rebounded on them in a spectacular manner, which I find myself feeling happy about, for Nokia. Know I should not feel pleased that M$ got a kicking, but I do. M$ began as a company that innovated, but massive amounts of money led IMO to a power complex and a desire to use other people’s ideas and innovation.
When the Thought Police arrive at your door, think -
I'm out.June 30, 2018 at 1:28 pm #22454I thought that Ed’s summary was ‘on the money’. Nokia largely if not completely missed the new wave phones market and MS had no idea except that they realised it was passing them by. MS thought that they had a product in terms of an OS and hoped that Nokia had the ability to graft together the hardware that could get them back into the game. It did not help that MS then stuffed in some of their people to look in the wrong direction. As was said elsewhere hardware and an OS were not enough. It turned out that you also needed a market place that sold an impressive range of things to optionally sit on the hardware. Not for nothing some nick named MS’s store Tumble Weed park. What I suspect MS did not ‘get’ was that the modern mobiles were not seen as mobile phones at all. They are not accessories to life, they are now many (most?) people’s lives. I shove mine in an inside pocket or leave it on a desk when at home, (reception is rubbish, use the landline). Most keep their’s in their hands almost all the time, even if it gets in the way of other aspects of life. While MS wanted to be in on that full scale involvement in people’s lives, I venture they did not and still do not really relate to what it means for a supplier to support that new way. Their other efforts produced only the wreckage of failed projects, such as their music offerings – did anyone ever use them? I stuck with my 6230 for ten years, it just did what I needed. I will not stick with my current phone for much longer, it fights me too much, so what to do when I fling it against the wall a final destructive time? But then I am different, so my needs are very different and the market ignores me, just as it did MS.
June 30, 2018 at 2:46 pm #22455Nokia now isn’t the Nokia of old.they are far smaller and manufacture their device via china now.
Ms owned the brand name for a few years, that lapsed about 2 years ago.
Ms all but killed the windows phone about 3 years ago, and I think its officially dead now.
Coincidentally on Thursday, I was set next to a guy in the theatre with a windows phone. Only the second one I’ve ever seen in the wild. The other was a windows 7 phone about 7 years ago. The first windows phone, after win mobile era.
I did buy a cheap win phone just to check not out.it was ok, but the app store was terrible.lack of apps,and a mass of rip off and spam apps.
June 30, 2018 at 3:27 pm #22456Like Duke I bought a Windows phone to play about with. The OS was very intuitive – it was very stable but yeah – app support was next to nothing. The worst thing to me was – given the branding and the parent company – it didn’t integrate with (computer) Windows at all. Android and IOS played much nicer with Windows Networks than their own (MS) phones.
I think the timing all coincided with the Windows 8 disaster and was part of that major downturn in their fortunes. They pretty much made the wrong decision at every time for a couple of years and steered a whole new generation of potential users away from windows.
They are still at it now by making Windows 10 seemingly worse at every update – adding useless features and removing or breaking useful ones.
June 30, 2018 at 5:00 pm #22457it didn’t integrate with (computer) Windows at all. Android and IOS played much nicer with Windows Networks than their own (MS) phones. I think the timing all coincided with the Windows 8 disaster and was part of that major downturn in their fortunes. They pretty much made the wrong decision at every time for a couple of years and steered a whole new generation of potential users away from windows. They are still at it now by making Windows 10 seemingly worse at every update – adding useless features and removing or breaking useful ones.
That sounds like the reason for their total failure put as clearly as possible.
June 30, 2018 at 5:25 pm #22458Cheers Richard – the phone was crazy – you turned on local WiFi and it wouldn’t find any devices on your Windows Network – iphones and androids did this with ease. There was a lot to like about the phone OS itself but the MS determination to make PCs, tablets and phones “the same” was a disaster for them. If they were “the same” people wouldn’t have all three or at least two of the three platforms.
Windows 8.1 had a superb implementation of OneDrive – which they then killed with W10, then brought back but worse than before,to the extent that I now just use the cloud version. They also had excellent DLNA/UPNP integration with Edge (only thing that made it worth clicking on) – which they have since killed.
Many giant windows updates later I wonder “why”……and am more or less plodding forward with MS and Windows out of habit.
June 30, 2018 at 5:56 pm #22459I didn’t know they was still making win phones. And don’t understand why they still are. No matter how good a device they build, That war has long been lost.
The expectation of a Windows PC in your pocket, just never materialised. Which was sad as Samsung back in 2013 (note2) had a dock able os that worked great. This is aside from the decent integration with Windows.android already had via many great apps. (push bullet is my fav still) .
Ios has great Mac integration, so Ms have not real excuse.
All that aside, they was just too late to the party, all the devs was invested in the larger platforms.
The os was rather nice, my phone was very cheap, very low end, (it came free with a tablet, iirc £80 for both) but it ran very smooth, far better than cheap androids of the day. It’s media hub (or sothign like that) that pooled all your messages and emails into one thread was great. So they killed it, and sky drive worked great too, again that was killed.
Steve Balmer famously said the iPhone was an overpriced toy, no business man would touch it. Hence Ms being slow off the mark.
It was DOA. A real shame and underhand they way they took control of Nokia and f-ed it up. I took a proper dislike to Ms after that. 1000s of Scandinavian jobs went to the wall, along with one of the best phone makers out there.
June 30, 2018 at 7:09 pm #22462Thanks for the replys guys.
Fuuny thing my lumia denim 535 died the other day. I had that phone for 3 years and the biggest problem for me was the calibre of the hardware for the 535. Signal and touch screen was a big proble.
So I decided to go with windows again and got the 640 and hardware wise its a total gem massivley out shinning the 535.
I got the 535, 3 years ago for £70 and I got the 640 new £70. The 640 is a real quality smart phone and I caanot fault it harware/OS/or apps.
See my new phone playing space invaders and the gorilla glass touch screen is amazing compared to the 535.
June 30, 2018 at 7:12 pm #22463M$ clearly cocked up on low calibre modles like the 535 and I figure thats what killed off M$ phone? 🙂
July 1, 2018 at 8:08 am #22470IMO what killed the Windows Store (and phone) was M$ trying to milk developers and mistreating them by continually changing the supported software.There was no stability and you paid £000’s to find that out.
Development on the Android is free, and even development on Apple has a relatively low cost of entry (assuming you have bought into their exorbitantly expensive hardware). On Windows you pay a fortune to get a full developers pack for Visual Studio.
Was it surprising that developers went where they were welcomed?
July 1, 2018 at 8:03 pm #22502M$ clearly cocked up on low calibre modles like the 535 and I figure thats what killed off M$ phone?
I disagree, their lowed phones offered somthing android and Apple just didn’t have at the time. A good cheap device. It’s was their top end that suffered, as it was priced like iPhones or android flagships but never delivered the same experience.
What soon happened was, the low end cpus ect… Got good, so we seen the emergence of cheap good android phones, around 2013 with the Moto G and E, and quickly followed behind them was the first one plus phone. Since then, we have been awash with great cheap phones.
Now you need to be a bit simple to have a top tier Android or ios device.
yes, I know I have one, but unless you want the best camera experiance, I couldn’t recommend a top tier phone to anyone. Even then there is little between a 2015 top tier (nexus 6p) and 2018 big boys like the S9 or P20p. Youre really splitting hairs.
The kids moto G (last years) has a camera that is on par with a 2015 flag ship (give or take).
One issue windows phones had with their great cameras on their flag ships was shutter lag, so even when they had the 20mp lumina, it just wasn’t very good for ‘snaps’ . Back then an 8mp iPhone wiped the floor with all, in the daily photo department. So ms stongest positive was also it’s biggest issue. And when the phone is £700, that stands out.
The cheaper 100 windows phones from the era, had terrible cameras, as did the Moto G that was 100, but the consumers expectations was so much lower. As a smart phone both worked excellently. Before that cheap windows phone was against the likes of the HTC wildfire or the Samsung galaxy y (as in why bother). Windows phones was miles ahead of them cheap androids, mainly cos the windows os was tailored for the hardware, and would run very well. Sadly for ms good hardware got cheap, and Android shortcomings wasn’t so obvious.
Not to mention, Windows Phone just wasn’t cool. Which goes along way in covering up cracks.
July 6, 2018 at 1:06 am #22697MS had missed the mobile OS boat and they knew it. Their big idea was to leverage their dominance in the desktop market to get on board hence Windows 8. The thinking was that if people got used to using Windows with tiles on their desktops they would want it on their phones. The result instead was that no one wanted Windows 8 !
July 6, 2018 at 10:25 am #22706The Andromeda (nee Courier) is rumoured to be both a foldable pad AND a Win10 phone.
I dunno about the pad aspect, but it could be an ideal ‘personal assistant’ format, assuming they get Edge to start to rival its competitors.
July 6, 2018 at 11:45 am #22711assuming they get Edge to start to rival its competitors.
Well that’s dead then. ?
July 6, 2018 at 2:08 pm #22712I on’t know whether I’m impressed or astonished that MS are still trying to compete in the portable space. The ship sailed so long ago you think they’d just let it quietly go away. On Edge – it s going backwards and I can’t think of a sigle reason to use it (it used to have a couple of useful features). MS basically have a share of laptops, the shrinking PC market and next to nothing of tablets and phones. If I was them I’d protect what I still have – their update cycle is definitely testing my patience and there must be a lot of other like me.
July 6, 2018 at 2:56 pm #22713Side question for all 10 users: if and when I get my laptop (maybe a year down the line) will the version of 10 Pro I want be already updated, or will I still have to struggle as most of you appear to be doing, with all those updates, some of which are actually wrecking machines?
I have a sneaking feeling that, whilst 7 is a ‘finished’ product that works fine with Updates carefully chosen by the user,* 10 is an ongoing nightmare. Probably because M$ want it like that.
*and ain’t that the person who should really matter? The user, the customer, the App Client? M$ have it Bassackwards as usual, because they want it that way.
When the Thought Police arrive at your door, think -
I'm out.July 6, 2018 at 3:04 pm #22715While some have had problems I am sure, we run 5 Windows 10 machines in this household. Apart from a couple of them heavily delaying one update a while ago and needing a force to be applied update method, they have all pretty much been trouble free. A few old programs have fallen by the way side, some replaced by the writer and others simply abandoned. One old XP era 32 bit program still works after a slight application of the fudge factor to its driver file. One of the PCs is a ten year old Vista era portable, one a 6 year old, (could be 7) portable and the three desktops are about 7 years old so no recent, ‘made for Windows 10’ devices.
July 6, 2018 at 3:09 pm #22716I’d have a long hard think about whether or not you NEED Windows. I don’t anymore. I’ve yet to find anything my Chrome/Android machine can’t do. Usually easier and cheaper than on Windows.
My X220 is only used to do updates and check it’s working, only reason I have it still is I still sometimes get asked Windows questions but it’s mostly tv streaming and Android these days.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
